Tuesday, October 28, 2014

Crititcal Response The Awakening

     In Feminist or Naturalist, Nancy Walker examines the Chopin’s true purpose in having Edna act as she does over the course of the plot. Walker furthers this idea through explaining multiple instances in the novel that may lead the readers to believe the story is one of feministic nature. But, once Walker analyzes Edna’s actions, the readers are led to believe the story is more of naturalistic nature, rather then feministic. I agree with Walkers criticism of the story, as I believe that Edna may not actually be a symbol of feminism. The author’s portrayal of Edna depicts her as lacking meaningful control over her actions as a result of the Creole society, which then allows for fate to take control of her life.
      Walker initially puts it bluntly, “Chopin did not intent to write a feminist tract.” (Walker 252). By openly stating her belief on Chopin’s true purpose, the authors are immediately led to questions her motives as well. Also, Walker reveals that Edna  “is not flaunting the mores of the society she finds herself in” (Walker 253). Walker depicts a clear contrast, between women’s roles in both Edna’s childhood town in Kentucky, to the more scandalous Creole society. At the start of The Awakening, the author has Edna conveys her initial discontent with the society as “[Creoles] freedom of expression was at first incomprehensible to her” (Chopin 12). This quote initiates the contrast being drawn in the story as Edna was raised in a conservative household, but once she moved to the Creole society, her beliefs and actions changed. Chopin is also able to achieve aforementioned contrast through the use of foil characters. In the story, the character Adele is used to draw clear differences between someone who values motherhood/marriage and someone who feels society constrains women. This idea is seen through the description,  “heroine of romance and the fair lady of our dreams” (Chopin 11). This almost positive characterization of Adele successfully portrays that feminism cannot be Chopin’s purpose in The Awakening.
       In Walkers critisizm, she explores the idea that Edna never truly acts based on what she wants, solely acting based on emotional thoughts.. She illustrates that in Chopin "giving herself over to emotion, Edna has allowed her decisions to be made below the conscious level... and she gives little thought to the consequences” (Walker 255). This is evident in the story through Edna's decision to move into her own house, as this illustrates her motives as for herself, almost selfish.  After deciding to seperate herself from her husband through the move, Edna cannot give a good explanation for her actions. As opposed to defending her actions, she sits in silence, accepting her decision to defy societal expectations. This inability to defend her actions makes Edna seem immature or weak, as she is seemingly unable to act logically. In conclusion, Walker decides that Edna is never necessarily a character portrayed to depict feministic traits, as her character succumbs to societies restrictions and is unable to make logical thoughts based on her beliefs

Monday, October 27, 2014

The Awakening Ch. 31-39 Dialectical Journals


Quote:
Explanation/Significance:
“Robert had never known the house and looked at it with interest. ‘I never knew you in your home,’ he remarked. ‘I’m glad you did not.’” (Chopin 134).
This instance is significant to Chopin’s character development for numerous reasons. By illustrating that Edna does not desire Robert to comprehend the life she lived in her former house, it portrays to the reader her realization of the societal restraints of her past. In terms of Roberts character development, Chopin uses this scene to show Roberts understanding of Edna's past.
“You are the embodiment of selfishness… I feel your neglect and indifference” (Chopin 143).
The quote regarding Roberts feelings towards Edna from the perspective of Edna is utilized to depict the problems with their relationship. After Roberts return from Mexico, Robert and Edna appear distant from each other. She feels he is selfish for returning and not visiting her, even though before the trip they claimed they were mutually in love. But upon his return, the relationship was weak resulting from the lack of communication both before and after his return. The author uses these quotes to show that communication is key within relationships in order to continue mutual feelings.
“How strange and awful it seemed to stand naked under the sky! how delicious! She felt like some new-born creature, opening its eyes in a familiar world it had never known”
In the final chapter of the novel, it is clear to the readers that Ednas transformation is complete. Chopin details her awakening as someone who had lots of life experiences, but is now seeing life in an entirely new way. This is a vivid description of her realization, and develops the reader's understanding of her newfound beliefs.

Thursday, October 23, 2014

The Awakening Ch. 21-30 Dialectical Journals


Quote:
Explanation/Significance:
“What should I do if he stayed home? We wouldn't have anything to say to each other” (Chopin 93).
This quote is significant as it questions Edna’s loyalty to Leonce and almost concluded their relationship. By stating that they would not know what to say to eachother, Edna is making it clear that the relationship is extremely weak and fragile. So, in turn, the author is portraying this statement in order to further her purpose that women do not need men to constrain their lives.
“Betrayed into an act of infidelity… ‘what would he think?’ She did not mean her husband; she was thinking of Robert Lebrun (Chopin 104).
This instance is important in the development of plot and purpose within the story as it is a major turning point for Edna. This is one of the first times she opening admits to being in love with Robert, as opposed to her husband. This illustrates the author's purpose as it is clear that the moment she comes to this realization, she will never go back to her husband. Also, it is possibly foreshadowing her leaving the marriage for someone else.
“She drank the liquor from the glass as a man would have done” (Chopin 106).
This is a significant statement that shows Ednas transformation was complete. She does things that men would generally shun women for doing, such as disobeying her husband and drinking hard liquor. This is the first sign of Edna’s true awakening as she internally discovered that she should not be constricted by man's actions.

Wednesday, October 22, 2014

The Awakening Ch. 11-20 Dialectical Journals


Quote:
Explanation/Significance:
"Another time she would have gone in at his request. She would, through habit, have yielded to his desire" (Chopin 41)
This instance within the novel is important as the author uses repetition of specific words, “she would,” in order to depict the contrast between the past and the present. As a result of Edna’s realizations, she decides she can voice her differing opinions and act based on her own ideas, not her husbands. The realization is first portrayed in this instance, and it is significant as she recognizes how in the past, she subjected to his orders, but now she can act based on her own desires.
“Good-by, my dear Mrs. Pontellier; good-by” (Chopin 60)
This example is significant to the understanding of the authors purpose, as this modest farewell from Robert to Edna has a much deeper meaning than initial thoughts would believe. As Robert and Edna’s scandalous relationship progresses throughout the plot, it is clear that the characters are far more than mere acquaintances, which is what his farewell statement would imply. The author has Robert refers to her by honorific “mrs” in order to show that he accepts that she is married. Which, in turn, illustrates how both the characters have extremely conflicting ideas regarding if one should submit to societal expectations, as she clearly feels that women should be able to do what they want. While on the other hand, Robert believes that one should respect the institution of marriage.
“‘I simply felt like going out, and I went out.’ ‘Well, I hope you left some suitable excuse...’ ‘No, I left not excuse.’” (Chopin 68)
For her entire marriage, Edna submitted to her husband's orders to see suitors every tuesday. But this is a significant instance of defiance on Edna’s part of the marriage. He expected her to see the suitors, and if she did not he expected her to at least leave an acceptable excuse. By not submitting to his desires, she is acting out against societal expectations of women in the role of “mother.” Furthering Chopin’s development of her idea that women do not need to be constricted by men’s expectations and beliefs.

Tuesday, October 21, 2014

The Awakening Ch. 1-10 Dialectical Journals


Quote:
Explanation/Significance:
“In short, Mrs. Pontellier was not a mother-woman… they were women who idolized their children [and] worshiped their husbands” (Chopin 10).
This quote is significant as it somewhat questions Edna’s parenting and motherhood. By comparing and contrasting her qualities to those of other women who are considered “mother-woman” is utilized to develop the idea that women should not be required by society to have children and marry. The author furthers this idea through her use of strong syntax as it aids her in achieving her purpose of portraying the importance of women branching out from the standard restrictions set on them by society.
"At a very early life she apprehended instinctively the dual life -- that outward existence which conforms, the inward life that questions" (18).
This instance is representative of how even during childhood, Edna was unsure about her beliefs regarding women within society. She demonstrates that even though she does not feel she should give in to male power and the typical role in the house as a mother, she still decided to marry and have children. During this era, the average woman would have been in the same position of Edna.
"She waited in vain. She saw no pictures of solitude, of hope, of longing, or of despair. But the very passions themselves were aroused within her soul… she trembled, she was choking, and the tears blinded her" (Chopin 35).
This is significant as it indefinitely shows the emotions within Edna, which cause her to question her life. This sadness and regret is evident in the story, and the author uses different techniques to achieve this idea.

Friday, October 3, 2014

"Happy Endings" Structure/Style Journal

Quote:
Style/Syntax:
“This is the end of the story”
Declarative Sentence
“John is a rat, a pig, a dog”
Metaphor
“Mary falls in love with John but John doesn’t fall in love with Mary”
Parallelism
“"Remember,this is Canada”
Setting
“The other John will emerge like a butterfly from a cocoon, a Jack from a box, a pit from a prune”
Simile
"But Mary isn't impressed by him, she's impressed by James, who has a motorcycle and a fabulous record collection"
Characterization
“Inside John, she thinks, is another John”
Split Sentence
“They buy a charming house. Real estate values go up”
Short, choppy sentences
“John and Mary die. John and Mary die. John and Mary die”
Repetition
“Now try How and Why”
Rhetorical Question

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

"The One Who Walk Away From Omelas" Analysis

     In her short story "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas," Ursula Le Guin explores the benefits and drawbacks of a relatively utopian society. Through her use of symbolism, setting, and situational irony Le Guin reveals that corruption within society is necessary for the wellbeing of the majority.

     Le Guin depicts the child’s suffering in the basement to symbolize the corruption of Omelas’ supposedly utopian society. The immorality within the society that is portrayed through symbolism is necessary to reveal how the suffering of the few, promotes the well being of the general public. The adults within Omelas’ are fully aware of the child’s immoral conditions, but they disregard their own morale’s in order to maintain their prosperity. The deliberate depravation of the child merely affirms the idea that even within a “perfect” society, corruption triumphs civility. The author could not achieve her purpose through symbols alone however, so Le Guin utilizes setting to portray the contrast between Omelas and other societies. The author illustrates the setting as a large, beautiful society in which a child is locked in a basement. The separation of adult and child through the setting demonstrates the isolation the child faces, therefore achieving the purpose of displaying the corruption within the society being necessary for the overall wellbeing of the society. Lastly, the author utilizes situational irony in order to truly expose that the Omelas is not similar to other societies. The readers initially consider that the society treats everyone equally, however the child in the basement creates a difference between expectation and reality. The suffering of the child successfully aids the Le Guin in achieving her purpose of demonstrating the strengths and weaknesses of a corrupt, supposed utopian society.