Sunday, September 21, 2014

"Cathedral" Questions 1, 2, 3, 5, 6

1. The first person narrator of "Cathedral" reveals himself as unsure of the strength of his marriage and the general discomfort he feels regarding the blind. Within the first few paragraphs, the author portrays an extremely negative connotation with the blind. The narrator depicts Robert, the blind man, as almost threatening through his extremely judgmental tone. Through the indirect characterization we can infer that the husband is uneasy about blind man by the way that the narrator describes his wife and the blind mans relationship, as strong and open. We can characterize the narrator as uncertain and uncomfortable from the first few paragraphs.

2. The narrator leads us to anticipate the meeting with the blind man will be something life changing, but when they meet Robert is surprised to see that the blind man fits the mold of a normal person. From the start of the story, the narrator seems to foreshadow a meeting with the blind man as something that would completely change his life. My initial response to Robert differed from the narrators as his response was based on a preconceived notion of certain attributes of blind people. However, once the narrator begins to realize that Robert’s personality is actually relatively similar to his own. As the narrator develops a relationship with Robert, the readers see the transformation of beliefs from that of blindness equating to weakness, to the belief that Robert is actually interested in improving himself and his society by being engaged in actual real-life situations. In the midst of the story, the author uses the narrator’s conversations and thoughts regarding Roberts’s ability to perform basic tasks, such as smoking, to develop the narrator’s character. Then, by the end of the short story, the readers understand the narrator’s belief that Robert’s inability to see does not affect his personality, and therefore sees him as a regular person.

3.) Throughout the short story “Cathedral,” the constant reference to blindness is develops the idea that a physical disability has little correlation with one’s ability to function in society. Initially in the story, the subject of blindness is addressed by the wife as signifying strength through overcoming the obstacles associated with it. This is evident with the strong imagery in the poem recalling her first interaction with the blind man. This adds meaning to the message of the story as it directly contradicts the majority’s opinion about physically disabled people. The narrator’s conviction regarding those who are blind was important as it contrasts his wife’s opinions about Robert, as the narrator viewed the disability as dismal and depressing. There are several more references to the narrator’s opinion as the story progresses, but as Robert is taught to draw, the narrator addresses blindness in a different light. Through the narrators inability to orally depict a cathedral, the idea develops that one who suffers from a physical disability such as blindness, will never be able to fully grasp the fundamental aspects of society. As a result of Robert’s enlightenment about the appearance of cathedrals, the readers develop the idea that the narrator’s preconception of blind people is indefinitely false.

5.) The author purposefully fails to reveal the narrators discovery in his epiphany with the purpose of forcing readers to draw their own conclusions based on opinion and not environmental influence. Through his open-ended conclusion to the story, the narrator is allowing readers to determine their own beliefs regarding blindness. At the end of the short story, the reasoning behind the narrator’s decision to keep his eyes closed was unclear as well. All of this information is suppressed in order to elicit free thought among readers regarding the result and accuracy of the drawing.


6.) The narrator is portrayed by the author as demonstrating an extremely habit based lifestyle, in which there is little variety of thought and actions. In his opinion, he works a boring job and as a result needs to isolate himself to stay sane. Contrastingly, his wife is an extremely sensitive and kind-hearted person who seems to enjoy social interactions and has a desire to help other people. Carver only portrays their relationship as weak to some degree, while mostly remaining indifferent about the numerous events occurring as the plot develops. Through this indifference and lack of judgment, the readers are permitted to draw their own opinions and ideas regarding their relationship. In my opinion, the only aspect of the narrator’s life that I would criticize is his original narrow-minded opinion regarding the abilities of physically disabled people.

No comments:

Post a Comment