Tuesday, October 28, 2014

Crititcal Response The Awakening

     In Feminist or Naturalist, Nancy Walker examines the Chopin’s true purpose in having Edna act as she does over the course of the plot. Walker furthers this idea through explaining multiple instances in the novel that may lead the readers to believe the story is one of feministic nature. But, once Walker analyzes Edna’s actions, the readers are led to believe the story is more of naturalistic nature, rather then feministic. I agree with Walkers criticism of the story, as I believe that Edna may not actually be a symbol of feminism. The author’s portrayal of Edna depicts her as lacking meaningful control over her actions as a result of the Creole society, which then allows for fate to take control of her life.
      Walker initially puts it bluntly, “Chopin did not intent to write a feminist tract.” (Walker 252). By openly stating her belief on Chopin’s true purpose, the authors are immediately led to questions her motives as well. Also, Walker reveals that Edna  “is not flaunting the mores of the society she finds herself in” (Walker 253). Walker depicts a clear contrast, between women’s roles in both Edna’s childhood town in Kentucky, to the more scandalous Creole society. At the start of The Awakening, the author has Edna conveys her initial discontent with the society as “[Creoles] freedom of expression was at first incomprehensible to her” (Chopin 12). This quote initiates the contrast being drawn in the story as Edna was raised in a conservative household, but once she moved to the Creole society, her beliefs and actions changed. Chopin is also able to achieve aforementioned contrast through the use of foil characters. In the story, the character Adele is used to draw clear differences between someone who values motherhood/marriage and someone who feels society constrains women. This idea is seen through the description,  “heroine of romance and the fair lady of our dreams” (Chopin 11). This almost positive characterization of Adele successfully portrays that feminism cannot be Chopin’s purpose in The Awakening.
       In Walkers critisizm, she explores the idea that Edna never truly acts based on what she wants, solely acting based on emotional thoughts.. She illustrates that in Chopin "giving herself over to emotion, Edna has allowed her decisions to be made below the conscious level... and she gives little thought to the consequences” (Walker 255). This is evident in the story through Edna's decision to move into her own house, as this illustrates her motives as for herself, almost selfish.  After deciding to seperate herself from her husband through the move, Edna cannot give a good explanation for her actions. As opposed to defending her actions, she sits in silence, accepting her decision to defy societal expectations. This inability to defend her actions makes Edna seem immature or weak, as she is seemingly unable to act logically. In conclusion, Walker decides that Edna is never necessarily a character portrayed to depict feministic traits, as her character succumbs to societies restrictions and is unable to make logical thoughts based on her beliefs

1 comment: